Discover-the-Difference

Bay Lakes Builders is an award-winning custom home builder in Green Bay, WI serving Door County and  Northeast Wisconsin.  Since 1989, Owner Paul E. Soletski and his team have developed many new neighborhoods while designing and building hundreds of new homes.  As a fully-licensed MLS real estate company in the State of Wisconsin, Bay Lakes also provides real estate brokerage services to buyers and sellers.  

Guildmaster Award Winner

Bay Lakes Builders is an award-winning custom home builder in Green Bay, WI serving Door County and  Northeast Wisconsin.  Since 1989, Owner Paul E. Soletski and his team have developed many new neighborhoods while designing and building hundreds of new homes.  As a fully-licensed MLS real estate company, Bay Lakes also provides real estate brokerage services to buyers and sellers.  

Bay Lakes Builders is proud to have won 14 Guildmaster awards for customer satisfaction. GuildQuality, an independent third party, provides an important service to Bay Lakes Builders by administering post-construction customer satisfaction surveys on their behalf. Only those building professionals meeting strict metrics for response rate and recommendation rate are considered for the annual Guildmaster award.   All new custom home customers are required to be surveyed to be eligible for the award, so 'cherry-picking' is not allowed.

The awards are a result of Bay Lakes continued commitment to improve the building experience for their customers.  By having an independent third party soliciting the survey responses, Bay Lakes' customers are provided with a judgement-free sounding board for both praise and constructive criticism to allow Bay Lakes to better understand their customer's building experiences and make any needed process improvements.  A survey summary report, including many client comments, is available by clicking the button below.

Featured Plan: The Melrose 4

Starting at $319,900 On Your Lot

Custom Home Design

Turning Your Dreams Into Reality

House Plans

A Sampling Of Our Most Popular Floor Plans

We built a home before with a different builder. This experience was COMPLETELY different. Paul and Co. are very detailed. Compared to our first build, we had no fears of surprises. Building a home is a huge project and there will always be a couple issues that come up, but this went as smoothly as I could imagine possible. From our first meeting, I was impressed with Paul's level of detail. I'm extremely detailed, and he was bringing up things I hadn't thought of. We had met with other builders prior to our initial meeting with Bay Lakes Builders, and the difference was apparent right away - very professional, very detailed, very organized.

  • Jason and Holly S, Green Bay

We built a house with Bay Lakes 20 years ago and had a great experience so we went back to them to build our next home. Our recent experience was even better. It was a smooth process that was fun. The staff is all good people who enjoy their job and want your home building experience to be a positive. My wife really enjoyed working with Dawn who is an exceptional interior designer.

  • John and Julie R, Green Bay
This is third house we built with three different builders. Bay Lakes overall was the best we have worked with. 
  • Michael & Georgia B, Abrams, WI

This is the second time with Bay Lakes and the quality is spot on. The allowances are also better than most. Everyone was great to work with from the employees at Bay Lakes to the electrician, plumber, and all of the subs. Paul Soletski went over and above in helping me secure my lot and in the redesigning of my master bathroom. Dawn Soletski is knowledgeable and fun when selecting designs and Ryan Soletski is precise and accurate in all of the budget processes!

  • Guy & Susan O, Green Bay

We first met Bay Lakes at the Brown County Showcase of Homes and were impressed with their dedication to the prep work and making sure there were no surprises along the way. I can tell you, they absolutely do just that! They put in the work to get accurate numbers and give you a complete breakdown of where the budget goes; and we had zero surprises along the way...we actually even came in under budget!  Dawn was fantastic with helping with flooring, tile, cabinets, you name it and she was available to help in the selection process. Mike was also outstanding in his communication of when final selections had to be made, and helping provide examples of different options for us to see.

  • Stephen & Katie S, Greenleaf, WI 
I would recommend Bay Lakes Builders. They were easy to work with, professional, and do quality work. When searching for a builder to build our home, we interviewed other builders, but got the best vibe from Bay Lakes. They pride themselves in treating their customers like family - it did not go unnoticed.
  • Bradley & Melissa P. Ledgeview, WI

We were most satisfied with the level of communication and the immediate response to any question. Paul and his team are equipped with an experience base that is outstanding and required to custom design a home. Every sub is an expert and they performed meticulous, perfect work in a professional manner!

  • Lincoln & Susan M, Bailey's Harbor, Door County, WI

Communication and attention to detail seemed to have a strong influence on Bay Lakes.  They spent many hours listening to us and helping us make decisions about the plan for our dream retirement home. They were attentive to our wants, needs, and budget. They helped us balance those three to optimize our results.

  • Mark & Jean S, Sevastopol, Door County, WI

Strongly recommend Bay Lakes Builders. Excellent quality. Paul and Dawn had some great ideas during the planning process.  Dawn is such a great asset to the team. The house (in our opinion) looks amazing due to her ability to guide us through the selection process. We had a really good idea of what we wanted, but she made it happen. She really helped us not only pick the correct 'white' or 'grey' or whatever it was we were working on but also was cognizant of our budget. Big win for the stone she was able to secure for us within our budget as well. Ryan is on the ball. Really helped the numbers side of the project come together for us and stay on budget (with what was controllable). Dan was on-site and kept the subs in order and our home was completed on-time for our Fall Showcase. I have referred them and continue to refer them to others. They really have a great team of subs that they work with and can count on to get the job done and done right. We've had a few things that needed to be resolved after our construction and we have had no issues with the subs coming back out to do what was needed. Excellent follow up by their team and their subs. I have referred them and continue to refer them to others. 

  • Jonathan and Desiree P, Wrightstown

We had absolutely no inclination to build a home but couldn't find one that suited our needs. The process was actually easy (and to our surprise fun) and came in on time and on budget. Paul is very good at conceptualizing and Ryan, Dan and Dawn accurately converted the concept into reality. We're not particularly good at color coordination but Dawn assisted us with the selections and always knew the relative costs of the options. We're extremely happy with the final result and certainly couldn't have come close to this look without Dawn. They are very cognizant of costs. The initial proposal allowed for quality materials throughout. When we exceeded the budget because we wanted upgrades such as the heat pump, air exchanger or tankless water heater, Ryan immediately indicated the exact price for the upgrades. Several of the subcontractors indicated the level of organization and competence exhibited by Bay Lakes was unequaled by any other contractor. If you're in the market for a quality home I'm not sure why you would use any other builder.

  • Michael & Janet S, Green Bay, WI

When we signed the contract to build, we were told by Bay Lakes they wanted the experience to be “fun”, and it was. They took the stress out of building the house especially since we live in Chicago and conducted a majority of the communication via e-mail, text and phone.

  • Robert P and Joseph B, Sturgeon Bay, Door County, WI

We chose them to build our home because of their creative designs and floor plans. They do not promote 'cookie cutter' homes. They are truly custom designed homes, built to what the customer wants. I appreciate Paul's energy and enthusiasm before and during the entire process. We truly felt like he was designing our house with our wants and needs in mind, but at the same time adding/suggesting some unique and interesting concepts in our plan, which we did incorporate. Mike, Dan, Ryan, Paul were all very responsive. Questions were answered quickly. I appreciate the extra time taken to further explain issues/items that I had no prior knowledge about in the building process, to at least get me an understanding of various steps in the building process.

  • Kurt and Jodi F, Green Bay

The team at Bay Lakes compliments each other nicely. They have Paul's insight on the home design and functionality side coupled with Dawn's interior design and aesthetic selections is awesome. But then they add Ryan, the financial guy, who works on the budget and keeps things realistic by being upfront in the beginning stages on whether you can keep things close to budget or not based on what you want your house to be. Dan, the project manager keeps things moving and on task and is quick to follow up. Every subcontractor we worked with was great!

  • Chris and Candee H, Green Bay

We could not be happier with our home. We ran into a couple problems and Bay Lakes had our back and helped resolve the issues quickly. Everyone that has walked into our home has commented how they love floorplan and design. A friend who works with a local building supply company was impressed with the quality of product being use in the home. They kept a very tight schedule. All of the subcontractors were some of the hardest working people I have been around. Everyone was focused on producing a great home.

  • Scott and Tammy S, Green Bay

Ready to learn more?

Contact us today to schedule a free consultation.

©2026 Bay Lakes Builders.  All Rights Reserved.

Website Designed + Administered by Ryan Soletski

Privacy Policy

Main Office:  1411 S. Webster Ave, Green Bay, WI 54301

Door County Office:  9352 Park Place, Fish Creek, WI 54212

PH 920.371.2956 • FX 920.437.7707 • Send Us A Message